Wednesday, July 15, 2009

Have a Horrible Day!


Today is the one-year anniversary of the release of Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog. If you have not yet seen it, watch it now. If you have seen it and love it like I do, show them some love in return.

Remember: It's not about making money, it's about taking money.

Monday, July 13, 2009

Mad Science Monday, 7/13/2009

Dammit. Dammit dammit dammit.

You might think from that intro that I'm writing about one of the more widely talked about science stories from this week. I may get to that one eventually, but the actual source of my frustration is the realization this morning that I had gotten the wrong paper for this week's entry. Sure, the one I got is mad, but I didn't get the one by the same group that involves rats with frikkin' laser beams attached to their heads. I'm going to try to give as much of an overview of all of that group's research as I can, but I can't for the life of me figure out how they made the stuff work in the laser rat story.

Update: I got the other paper in the middle of writing this, but I'm still focusing mostly on the newer paper; the one with the actual laser beams appears to use many of the same techniques, and I haven't had as much time to digest it, so I'll stick to the one I'm mostly grokking.

But I'm getting ahead of myself. First you're going to need some...

Mad Observations: A lot of observations are necessary to culminate in this level of mad science. There's too much to cover it completely, but let's see what I can get.

First, there's an archaebacterium, Natronomonas pharaonis, that makes a protein that pumps ions across the cell's membrane in response to light (specifically certain wavelengths of orange light). This pump is called the Natronomonas pharaonis halorhodopsin chloride pump, or NpHR. This pump has been adapted to be expressed in mammalian cells.

Next, there's the known mechanism of epileptic seizures, namely that the'rey caused by cascades of electrical potentials; basically, one cell has more positive charge inside than outside, and that causes it to induce the next cell to switch to the same condition, etc down a line.

Mad Reference: "Optogenetic control of epileptiform activity." Jan Tønnesen, Andreas T. Sørensen, Karl Deisseroth, Cecilia Lundberg, and Merab Kokaia. PNAS, published online before print July 6, 2009.

Mad Hypothesis: This paper even included a direct reference to the hypothesis they were testing: "Therefore, we tested a hypothesis that epileptiform activity can be optically controlled by selective expression of NpHR in principal cells." In other words, they thought screwing with the potential differences across membranes (by pumping chloride ions into those cells) would stop the epileptic cascade, and they figured they could induce that change with light by putting those pumps into the right cells. They also tested whether putting in the pumps (but not inducing them with light) caused any changes in the behavior of brain cells, and whether turning on the pumps caused any other problems (like sucking up too many chloride ions, stopping other things that need them from functioning properly).

Just to make sure that's clear, what they were testing is whether shining a laser beam inside a brain would work to stop seizures. Obviously.

Mad Experiment: It just keeps getting better. To test whether shining a laser on brains might be useful for treating epilepsy, they infected rats with a virus. Ok, this sounds all kinds of mad scientist, but it's actually a fairly well-established technique. This virus, technically a lentivirus, was modified to incorporate the gene for NpHR into cells that it infected. That gene was put under control of the calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase IIa (CaMKIIa) promoter, meaning that, no matter what cells the gene might get inserted into, the protein would only be expressed in certain cells--namely, brain cells. They also put the enhanced yellow fluorescent protein (EYFP) in the same virus, also under control of that promoter. That let them cut up some of the rat brains (and other rat bits) and confirm that the technique had worked to get the protein expressed in the right place, and not in the wrong places (because it'd be bad for light-sensitive proteins to be expressed on, say, the skin, where they'd be doing their thing all the time, not just in response to a frikkin' laser beam).

Most of the research, unfortunately, was done in cultured rat brain cells, using that same basic technique as I described above. But they showed that they could get the protein expressed in rat brains. That's important, since they'd already done other research with implanting frikkin' laser beams in rat brains, to stop Parkinson's tremors.

Yes, that's a photo of a rat having light beamed into its brain through a fiber optic cable attached to a laser. We truly live in amazing times.

So anyway, they got their protein into cells (both in rat brains and in cultured cells), and then they tested the cultured cells using established epilepsy tests. They did these tests on unaltered cells, altered cells without light, and altered cells with the correct wavelength of light shining on them.

They All Laughed, But: It worked. When they shined lasers on the altered cells, their idea worked; the seizures (well, technically simulated seizures, since it was just a plate full of cells) stopped. It looks like this would actually work. But the whole time I was reading it, I was thinking, "Um, so. You need a frikkin' laser beam implanted in your brain." But then I found out I was missing half the story, since they'd already implanted frikkin' laser beams in rat brains. So this whole thing would totally work, and all it takes is:
  • infection by a virus to put an archaebacterial protein into your brain,
  • glowing proteins engineered from jellyfish thrown in to make sure it worked,
  • surgery to implant a laser (or lasers) in your head, and
  • potentially a fiber optic system following you around (although I guess we're bigger than rats, so maybe the lasers could be worn directly).
I say this all jokingly, but apparently that's way better than the current system of curing intense seizures, namely cutting the hell out of the affected area, hoping you don't get too much that's useful.

Mad engineers: This one's all yours now. We scientists have shown it would work. Implementing this is all you.

Mad Science Monday Coming Soon

I'm trying to get another paper before writing this up. If I don't get the paper in time, I'll cover what I can from the one paper and the abstract of the other. In either case, I'll be back in a few hours with this week's Mad Science Monday. It's a crazy one, so stay tuned...

Wednesday, July 08, 2009

Subscribing to Specific Labels

I'm sure most of you reading this like to read everything I write, regardless of whether it's about politics, mad science, or food. However, some of you may only want to keep up on one aspect of my blogging. If so, here's how to subscribe to a specific label (aka tag) from my blog.
  1. Figure out which label you want (they're over there on the right), and note it. Make sure you have the spelling right. Click the label to see if there are any special characters you need (for example, "mad science" is actually "mad%20science", because the space has to be encoded as %20 so browsers can understand it; %20 is currently the only special encoding you need for any of my labels, but that could theoretically change in the future).
  2. Add that label to the end of this url: http://jonthegeek.blogspot.com/feeds/posts/default/-/ (for example, http://jonthegeek.blogspot.com/feeds/posts/default/-/mad%20science).
  3. Add that url to your favorite RSS reader
That's all it takes. Enjoy!

Note: The same trick works for any blog here on blogger, just replace "jonthegeek" with the url of the blog you want.

Monday, July 06, 2009

Mad Science Monday, 7/6/2009

It's Monday again (already!), so that means it's time for some mad science. It might not be immediately obvious how this week's article fits the theme, but I have one mad science stereotype stuck in my head now about this one, so hopefully I can get you there, too.

Mad Observations: Despite portrayals in media, scientists are human beings. Sometimes decisions made by human beings are clouded by emotion.

Mad Reference: "Large-Scale Assessment of the Effect of Popularity on the Reliability of Research." Thomas Pfeiffer, Robert Hoffman. PLoS ONE 4(6); e5996. 2009 June 24.

Mad Hypothesis: Research is not impacted by the trendiness of the subject of that research. Yes, I know; this is one of those hypotheses that is pretty much obviously untrue once you say it, but it's something nobody had said scientifically (and followed up with experimentation), and thus it was tacitly accepted as truth.

Mad Experiment: This is what's known as a meta-analysis paper. The researchers didn't perform experiments, per se. Instead, they analyzed over 60,000 published statements about 30,000 unique interactions between yeast proteins. This data set was drawn from papers focusing on specific interactions; each paper from which the 60,000 statements were drawn focuses on one or a few interactions, investigated using small-scale, focused experiments. They evaluated the "popularity" of the proteins involved in these interactions by how many times those proteins were mentioned (ie, more mentions = more popular).

They then compared that first data set to a second data set, gathered using high-throughput, mostly automated techniques. These high-throughput techniques don't focus on one or a few interactions, but instead test pretty much everything simultaneously. In other words, these techniques don't focus on anything in particular, so they don't "care" whether the interactions they're looking at are "popular" or "interesting."

They All Laughed, But: The reason this research seems mad sciency to me is that I keep imagining these researchers giving their speech about the popular researchers laughing at them. Well, who's laughing now?? It turns out, when you compare the results from the specific data with the results from the high-throughput data, popular proteins seem to get by on their looks. Specifically, interactions involving unpopular proteins tend to agree in the data sets more often than interactions involving popular proteins. Popular proteins have a higher proportion of likely incorrect interactions published than do unpopular proteins.

When I first read the summary of the research, I thought this might be an example of damned lies; I figured it wasn't necessarily that the unpopular protein research was correct more often, it was just that nobody bothered disproving statements about those losers. But the methodology here seems sound; it looks like the popular proteins really are getting treated differently. This points out a possible large flaw in current research, and a need to put more safeguards in place to prevent this stuff from getting through. Strong work, mad scientists. You have successfully exposed the flaws in the work of your enemies.